There’s no silver bullet: A case for picking and mixing payment provider traits
The Forrester Wave Report is a respected voice in research. It can help you choose a suitable merchant payment platform. However, the simple graph doesn’t tell the full story. It oversimplifies the payment platform possibilities. We look at ways to make their data relevant for you.
The payments market has been in a funny place during these last few years. Having been on the inside of the industry shift as banks stopped being the payment providers of choice and successful tech companies were formed, the three overriding knowledge points I’ve gained are:
Each merchant has their own requirements and they should understand those better before making a selection of provider
Since there’s so much investment in the payment industry, it’s important to understand where your potential partners are in their journey.
There is no silver bullet – no one single provider who performs the best in every scenario imaginable – and it’s hard to see one forming in the next five years.
Source: The Forrester Wave™: Merchant Payment Providers, Q3 2020
If you blindly look towards the top-right of the Forrester diagram you could easily make a less than optimal purchase decision for your business. This is the second Forrester report produced since 2018 and since that last report there’s been a lot of movement which isn’t fully explained. Thus, judging this change with a simple graph oversimplifies the payments landscape and merchant needs. There are a couple of providers that I would say are missing,
Whatever the reason for this, it would be interesting to see how Forrester would have ranked them.
Here are a few key points which are worth calling out.
Customers need to make the scoring relevant for them
Forrester has provided their score ranking which I encourage customers to review contextualize to their own business. Some will place a lower value towards omnichannel while some will give more value to Payouts & Disbursements. Relating this to your company needs is very important and impactful.
There are categories that I think have been missed and would also be important factors to consider. These include:
- commercial attractiveness
- acceptance rates across markets
- support model
- linking payment
- data to loyalty
- and optimization
Depending on your individual requirements, adding these categories could have a significant impact on the ranking of these suppliers.
I have been working in this industry for many years now and was privileged to have seen how some providers on this list are doing amazing things for their customers. Those great things were not included in this report, but they absolutely are a solid reason why the businesses selected their providers. I think, in producing this report, Forrester made some simplifications in explaining customer needs. This distorts the graph and re-emphasizes why personalizing your provider decision to your individual needs is a must.
One payment provider might not be enough
I just left a webinar with a customer of ours who stated: “We selected multiple payment providers for a couple of reasons. Firstly, we didn’t want to commit ourselves to one provider for many years as we deemed this too risky and, secondly, we couldn’t find a payment provider that met all our needs”. This highlights that picking and mixing the best parts of each payment provider is also a strategy many merchants take.
We see this with the ones who particularly understand the value of payments, but it’s definitely not the right scenario for many other merchants. There are providers on this list that are perfect for particular situations as a single supplier.
Oversight of them all
Working with all the providers from the strong performers and leaders categories, we see many happy customers, we see which providers are gaining the most customers and we see how they are helping their customers always be better. As a software service, we enjoy the privilege of sitting alongside customers and unlocking this value with their providers.
We also empathize with our customers as we see the challenges in choosing the right provider(s) for their business. It’s a fast moving industry with new names, upcoming names, and news almost every day. This is also just one part of commerce – we haven’t even touched on payment methods or fraud providers.
Ultimately, it’s very useful to see an independent review of the payments industry. While understanding the criteria to be part of this report it would still be interesting to see big domestic players in here and how they stack up against these global names, particularly in countries like Japan, Korea, China, Brazil where there are significant nuances.
The real takeaway for me is that customers need to adjust the weighting, consider if there are missing categories from the criteria and apply this information in a relevant way. And of course, as always, they should speak to those reference customers and the community.
I’d love to take predictions from everyone on what the graph will look like in 2 years time!
Developing a successful global business strategy is crucial for any business looking to expand beyond its domestic market. The benefits of entering the global market are endless. In this article, we will explore the main concepts of global business strategy.
Collecting tax forms is an essential process for marketplace business owners. In this article, we’ll discuss why it matters, how to do it efficiently, and how automation can improve the tax form collection process.
Welcome to our Reports and Research hub. Based on our leading position and experience in the world of cross-border business, our research reports aim to offer you our latest findings and global insights. Feel free to browse our reports and discover valuable resources to support your business’s growth and success.
Want to make and receive cross-border payments with ease? Payoneer gives you access to a universe of opportunities to make international payments, receive funds, and much more to run your global business. Read on to learn about how to get started using Payoneer today.
Every business owner needs to issue invoices. Learn what an invoice is, what you need to include on your invoices, and when you need to send them, and why tracking invoices is important for your business’ success.
What is payment fraud detection and what do you need to know to understand, detect, and prevent fraudulent activities. Discover the best practices, tools, and strategies to safeguard your business against payment fraud and protect your financial assets.
The basics of treasury management What is treasury management and why is it important? Treasury management plays a crucial role in the financial operations of businesses. This piece will explore the fundamentals of treasury management, its core functions, and its importance for businesses.
Accounts receivable (AR) is crucial for business success. By managing your AR process effectively, you can improve Your cash flow, increase revenue, and build better customer relationships. AR involves tracking and managing customer payments and outstanding balances. Our comprehensive guide will help you understand what AR is, And how you can optimize your AR process…
Accounting plays a vital role in the financial management of businesses and organizations. This guide will provide an overview of accounting, explaining its fundamental principles and processes. We’ll review types of accounting, key documents, special considerations, and more.